Mike is upset when Eve tells him that she does not want to continue their annual tradition of trick-or-treating because of her crush on Victor Blake (Kenton Duty), who has told her he thinks Halloween is immature and for kids. So, Mike decides to dress up Boyd and take him trick-or-treating, directly disobeying Kristin's wishes, and inadvertently brings home a kid wearing a costume similar to Boyd's. When calling on Ed, Mike meets his friend Elvira. Mike also gets a costume for Mandy but not quite as revealing as the one she wanted, while Vanessa's 'pirate princess' costume draws the attention of the Baxter's' neighbor Bill.